In the ten-plus years since its creation, Cowboy Bebop has aged like wine: incredibly well. Ask most mainstream viewers what their favorite anime series is, and they'll list this along with other like series with western themes such as Trigun or Ghost in the Shell. The most hardcore, sub-only otaku will admit that, yes, dubs can work because of this series. Bebop transcends fandom lines: hardcore and casual fans alike will all agree that this is a exceptionally good series and their favorite. This is our Batman: The Animated Series: an animated series that even those who’ve outgrown “cartoons” can look back fondly as being an excellent series. So in short the series has aged...but the legacy hasn't.
Let's look at Bebop's immediate successor: Samurai Champloo. Created by Shinnichiro Wantanabe a good five years after Bebop, Champloo continues the theme of taking two completely unrelated forms of media and mashing them together with better-than-expected results: Kurosawa-inspired samurai drama with American-style hip hop and rap. The characters are similar, in that we have a headstrong skilled martial artist (Mugen) pared off with a patient, stoic experienced warrior (Jin) and a girl who's trying to find out her mysterious past (Fuu) with a cute pet (Momo). All the like elements are there...and yet Champloo falls flat. I've seen it frontwards to backwards and compared to Bebop, Champloo just doesn't match up. The characters are less developed and complex compared to Bebop's beloved cast. The story's episodic and with weaker characters the individual plots come off as lacking. That’s the problem with making such a groundbreaking series: setting the bar so high. Given the similarities between both Bebop and Champloo, it’s apparent that Wantanabe tried to bottle lightning again and failed. Champloo is a good series, but it just doesn’t hold the Bebop magic.
In my humble opinion, Bebop’s true successor is…Black Lagoon. We have a crew of misfits including a stoic, imposing and bald leader who’s frequently frustrated with the crew’s enforcer; a violent, anti-social sociopath who’s dark past broke her into the bitch she is today. They are accompanied by a hacker who provides basic intel and communications for the job at hand. Together they add on another member and go around on jobs offering a service seen as reserved for the lowest of the low: pi-ahem…courier service. The main differences aside from the setting and the specifics of the job is one the violence. Lagoon’s level of violence is what Bebop was back in the day. While Bebop is John Woo meets Sergio Leone, Lagoon is John Woo meets Quentin Tarantino or Robert Rodriguez. In upping the violence to ultra-violence levels Lagoon successfully progresses off of Bebop much like how The Dark Knight did from Batman. When a medium progresses it’s given more leg room and often times grows more violent, and done well it’s an incredibly good thing.
The second difference, and a welcome one at that, is the wildly-different leads. Rock isn’t a hype-capable badass like Spike: he’s an ordinary salary man abducted by pirates and eventually drafted into their crew. He’s a pacifist and what he lacks in combat skills he more than makes up in his diplomacy skills. He’s the only one in the Lagoon company capable of solving problems outside of violence and has the skills to do it. He’s also, much like a newcomer to anime, a fish out of water. He finds himself in a completely alien concept and tries his best to adapt. While he’s trying to figure out what’s going on, we’re doing it with him. This makes him much more relatable than Spike, but it doesn’t make him a better character. Both characters suit their respective series’ needs: Spike’s a badass who we can’t exactly relate to but it doesn’t matter because we’re too busy cheering him on as he kicks epic amounts of ass while Rock is a pacifist who we can relate to since Revy’s the one kicking ass and he’s the witness like we are.
Lagoon’s Tarantino -inspired action and surprising depth from its very human characters and their philosophies (one quotes Jean-Paul Satare for crying out loud!) would of made it the next big thing since Bebop…and yet it wasn’t. What happened? To put it simply, it was a victum of circumstance: the right series in the wrong time. Lagoon was distributed here in the states around ’08, when we were knee-deep in the Great Recession. Companies were taking fewer risks and the price of producs went up. Geneon, Lagoon’s producer went belly-up in ’09 and thankfully the series was salvaged by Funimation. But Lagoon never received the same amount of marketing or exposure that Bebop did: it was never aired on Adult Swim or any other channel to the best of my knowledge. It was simply dead in the water: doomed to ironically lie adrift at sea.
The sad tale of Lagoon is an active symptom of the anime industry today: take fewer risks and try to capitalize off the established audience as much as possible. This is a sound decision in hard times: companies don’t have the funds to market themselves to the mainstream so they focus on the fanbase. Unfortunately, much like comics in the 90’s the industry anime is in that same transitional period and is dangerously close to crashing and becoming loss to obscurity. With comics it was grim and gritty with the success of Watchmen and The Dark Knight Returns while with anime it’s otaku-ness with the success of series such as The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya. The industry just isn’t learning: while otaku-favorites like Inuyasha kept fans going back in the day it was mainstream hits like Bebop that brought them in the first place. If the industry wants to maintain itself then they have to do a better job at finding a mainstream hit and marketing it further: spend more money on market research and extensive group testing. If we as fans of anime want to keep our medium alive then we have to do our best to promote the more mainstream-friendly classics like Bebop or Ghost in the Shell or even Trigun.
So what’s the next move? Well outside of a third season of Lagoon (fingers crossed, yo!) and the proper marketing, the industry should make do with what it has. Baccano is a worthy prospect and Adult Swim should probably invest a few hours into it. As far as creating a new Bebop, let me keep it nice and simple: classic western themes and conventions thru an exceptional eastern perspective and adaptation. Bebop, Shell, Lagoon, Trigun, and Baccano all share the same theme and are/were destined for mainstream success…they just need or needed a little bit of love.
That ends my Cowboy Bebop retrospective. Bebop was more than just an anime: it was our Batman: the Animated Series: an animated series that transcended fandom lines and mainstream sensibilities and became an instant classic and huge success. However, progress marches on, and it’s only a matter of time ‘till someone, somewhere finally produces our The Dark Knight…and hopefully we’ll be there to enjoy the ride. Thanks for reading, and, oh yeah:
See you next time, Space Cowboy.